Camp and Preseason (Part 2)
- September 20th, 2009
- Write comment
After today’s second round of cuts, here’s how the Kings’ roster looks:
GOALIES
Jonathan Bernier
Erik Ersberg
Jonathan Quick
DEFENSEMEN
Drew Bagnall
Andrew Campbell
Drew Doughty
Davis Drewiske
Matt Greene
Thomas Hickey
Jack Johnson
Alec Martinez
Sean O’Donnell
Joe Piskula
Rob Scuderi
FORWARDS
Dustin Brown
Marc-Andre Cliche
Kyle Clifford
Richard Clune
Alexander Frolov
Gabe Gauthier
Michal Handzus
Peter Harrold
Raitis Ivanans
Anze Kopitar
Trevor Lewis
Teddy Purcell
Brad Richardson
Brayden Schenn
Brandon Segal
Wayne Simmonds
Ryan Smyth
Jarret Stoll
Kevin Westgarth
Justin Williams
John Zeiler
For those counting, that’s 35 guys. Among those remaining are perhaps some surprising names. Essentially 12 more have to go before the regular season begins in just under two weeks. It’s easier at this point to talk about who I think goes than who I think stays, as there are some interesting battles left to be won.
Of the defensemen who are left in camp, Campbell, Bagnall and Piskula are almost certain to be sent to Manchester sooner than later. While I think Piskula could end up being a spare part, 7th D-man at the NHL level eventually, Campbell is still a project in the works and Bagnall is nothing more than a decent AHL defenseman at this point. If you assume (and rightly) that Johnson, Doughty, Greene, Scuderi, O’Donnell are all shoo-ins, that leaves Drewiske, Hickey and Martinez competing for one, possibly two roster spots if the Kings decide to carry 7 defensemen (unlikely since Peter Harrold can be inserted on D if needed, though not preferred). All three of these guys have impressed me so far and this is going to be an interesting battle. In my mind if anyone has a leg up, it’s Davis Drewiske for coming up and playing well at the end of last season. Hickey looks very close if not ready, but the organization can afford to be patient and give him some more experience in Manchester. Alec Martinez end up being the odd man out here.
Of the remaining forwards, it seems pretty certain that Kopitar, Smyth and Williams will be the Kings’ top line on opening day; Purcell, Stoll and Brown are likely the second line; and Frolov, Handzus and Simmonds as the third line.
Guys who are a relative certainty not to make the team in my mind: Gabe Gauthier, Marc-Andre Cliche, Trevor Lewis and Brandon Segal. Some of the other candidates for the 4th line openings:
Brayden Schenn – VERY promising. Kid does all the right things, and truth be told, could probably play in the NHL right now as an 18 year old. That said, I think before camp ends, he will end up being returned to Brandon of the WHL for another year of junior experience and an opportunity to play in the Memorial Cup this season. Based on what experts said at the draft, I had an expectation that Schenn was two or three seasons away from being a regular NHL player. Based on what I’ve seen with my own eyes, that’s a long time to wait for a guy with this much talent. Schenn will not only be an NHL player within two seasons, he’ll be a VERY good one.
Kyle Clifford – A hard nosed, hard working kid. I’ve been very impressed with Clifford’s game. Not afraid to get dirty in the corners. Not afraid to drop the gloves. Going to the the type of player other teams hate having to face in the near future. A little bit raw yet though. Can’t wait to see what he looks like in camp next year.
Richard Clune – Love him as an agitator. Plays the same role as Jon Zeiler but in my opinion, does it better. Not afraid to mix it up. Given the Kings’ glut of 4th line forwards, he’ll probably end up in Manchester
John Zeilier – Not sure what the organization’s love affair is with Zeilier. Occasionally effective an an energy player but adds nothing on the offensive end and takes a lot of unnecessary penalties. If it were up to me personally I’d stick him in Manchester and leave him there. Don’t see what good he is to the Kings.
Brad Richardson – Love his wheels, and he was a productive player in junior, but he looks absolutely snakebitten around the net. Can’t even finish during drills. Hard to believe we gave up a 2nd round pick for him. Should wear a nametag that says “Hi, My name is: Healthy Scratch”.
Peter Harrold – Like him much better as a 4th line forward than I do on defense. Based on how he’s been skating in camp, might end up centering the 4th line.
Kevin Westgarth – In today’s NHL, the hybrid type enforcer who has some hockey skill to boot is a good commodity. Westgarth is fearless and is a much better skater and puckhandler than Raitis Ivanans. If I’m choosing between one of our two “enforcer” types, Westgarth gets the nod.
Raitis Ivanans – Has one job to do: fight. Only one problem: When the Kings needed him to come to the aid of his teammates last season, he was invisible. Puck Bunnies wear his jerseys but in reality Ivanans is the most expendable and probably least talented player on the team. Slow skater, not good with the puck. Clogs up the neutral zone for his own teammates. Find a team like Washington who doesn’t have an enforcer and deal him for a late round pick or another spare part forward.
Regardless of what I think, the 4th line will probably consist of a rotating combination of all the above guys, with a probability that Clune and perhaps Westgarth start the season in Manchester.
Now for the goalies. Here’s where it gets really interesting. All three guys remaining on the roster are probably NHL ready. Quick looked very good despite allowing perhaps a questionable goal in his lone preseason appearance, and Bernier has looked solid in two complete games – outstanding in last night’s 4-1 win over Anaheim. Ersberg has played but half a game but is expected to start one of the next couple games. If I’m basing my decision about who stays and who goes to Manchester solely on talent and upside Quick and Bernier are on the opening day roster. Bernier looks by my estimation to be ready to make the jump to the NHL, however it won’t hurt him to get another year of AHL experience. It wouldn’t make much sense to keep him in LA to back up Quick, so the only way Bernier stays is if he wins the #1 job outright. With two weeks of camp left, that’s not out of the realm of possibility, but I have a feeling he will get to carry the load in Manchester with Jeff Zatkoff backstopping the Reign in Ontario again.
Tomorrow I’ll talk a little bit about some of the Kings’ regulars and what I think can be expected for the upcoming season.
-JS